Stingy Bali Tourists, Or Bali Government?
By Vyt Karazija
The chairman of Bali’s Tourism Board, Ida Bagus Ngurah Wijaya, opened his mouth wide last Wednesday, and firmly inserted his foot. Annoyed that, despite a rise in total tourist numbers to Bali, visitors are now staying for only an average of three or four days instead of the seven days which was the norm 10 years ago, and spend only US$100 per day instead of $300, he blamed the tourists.
“Stingy tourists” are overcrowding Bali, he whinged. “When they come, we have serious problems of traffic and waste. The island becomes dirty,” he said – falling headlong into the time-honoured local practice of blaming everyone else except yourself. It’s a little shocking to see officials – whose job it is to attract tourists – turn on their target market and accuse them of not being good little visitors by staying longer and spending more. It’s more than a little disconcerting to see a high-profile public official actually exhibit the same cargo-cult mentality that pervades many less sophisticated villagers here. In effect, he is saying: “You have it. We want it. Give it to us. If you don’t, you are a stingy bule.”
Well, Ngurah, you might think that, but as the voice of Bali tourism, you are not supposed to say it, because the backlash from tourists as a result of your rudeness will only result in a wider public discussion as to the real reasons that people are deserting Bali. I was a tourist for 12 years before coming here to live. Now, as a resident for over three years, I have constant contact with “stingy” tourists, and as a result of their feedback, I am happy to summarise for you just why this trend is developing.
Look around you, Ngurah – not with the rose-coloured glasses of a local, but through the eyes of someone arriving in Bali after a long, tiring flight. What do you see?
You will see tourists paying $25 each for a 30-day visa-on-arrival to enter the country, and then another $16 each to leave. Family of four coming for only five days? That’s $164 out of the spending budget already, and no way to save money on a one-week visa, because officialdom has withdrawn the short-stay visa facility. Visiting Bali on a cruise lay-over for six hours? That’s $25 per person, thanks.
You will see chaos, delays and inefficiency in a hot, overcrowded arrivals hall, with insufficient staff to handle the passenger load and a confusing queuing system.
You will see tired visitors being pounced on by “porters” at the baggage carousel and cajoled into letting them wheel their bags 20 metres to the customs desk, then stridently demanding $10 for each bag before running off to scam their next victim, as airport “security” personnel stand by and grin.
You will see the monopolistic taxi counter “mistakenly” ask for a rate higher than the official published rates displayed, then see their drivers try to con their passengers out of another Rp40,000 on arrival at their hotels and villas with a pathetic sob story, or an insistence that “this is the rule!” You will see arriving visitors quail as they face the long, long, crowded walk to their car during the chaotic and visitor-unfriendly airport reconstruction.
You will see tourists arrive at what are now grossly overpriced and over-starred hotels, which no longer offer the “book 7, get 10? incentive packages of past years, only to be told, “Sorry, your room is not ready.” Even Singapore hotels are now cheaper than those in Bali, which is no longer competitive.
You will see a proliferation of minimarts in garish colours selling monstrously overpriced items to the hapless tourist. Buy a local magazine there, published in Bahasa Indonesia, with a printed price of Rp25,000 on the cover, and you will be charged Rp55,000 when it is scanned. Shrug from the cashier. “Boss’ rules.”
You will see tourists being accosted by rude touts, women being physically manhandled by sellers who refuse to accept a polite refusal to buy their wares, stallholders muttering thinly veiled abuse at tourists who won’t pay four times the going rate in Bali (and twice the price in their home country) for their shoddy goods. You will see criminal moneychangers short-changing gullible tourists every day, and the arrogant taxi mafia (the non-Blue Bird companies) overcharging customers and threatening real taxi drivers with violence.
You will see tourists stuck in traffic for hours on Bali’s poorly maintained roads, because no one even considers the gridlocking consequences of allowing local drivers to park wherever they feel like. You will see suicidal motorbike riders come close to killing pedestrians with their brainless antics and causing accidents with cars, after which they shrilly demand compensation for their own stupidity.
You will see visitors to Bali try to negotiate the open drains with lids which masquerade as footpaths here, and injure themselves when brittle manholes collapse beneath them. You will see tourists with infants in strollers being forced to risk death by having to share the narrow roads with texting drivers and motorcyclists.
You will see tourists now being expected to pay the same prices as at home for mediocre Western-style meals, and absolutely exorbitant rates for imported wine, spirits and food. Spirits in bars are frequently counterfeit local replacements and deliberate half-shots in mixed drinks are common. Despite smokers being banned in all restaurants, bars and clubs from the first of June this year, tourists can expect no relief from the constant burning of toxic plastic waste all over Bali, the carcinogenic mosquito-fogging smoke and noise, or from the stinking emissions of the ubiquitous buses, trucks and illegal 2-stroke motorbikes.
You will see tourists give up on visiting the “cultural epicentre” of Ubud because of traffic jams and the hundreds of huge buses clogging the town. You will see them give up on visiting far-flung temples and seeing the “real” Bali, because it’s all too hard, and now too expensive. Eventually, you will see them avoiding the immense, noisy, polluted construction zone that is south Bali altogether.
You will see tourists recoil from the stinking piles of garbage on the beaches, on the streets and in the rivers. Where garbage is collected, it ends up in makeshift tips anywhere the collectors choose to dump it. Just have a look at the huge rat- and snake-infested mountain of refuse dumped opposite villa developments in Legian, just off Jalan Nakula; have a look at the environmentally disastrous heap of rubbish at the entrance to the Mangrove Park.
You will see tourists cautious of potentially rabies-infected dogs, scared of contracting dengue fever from the incessant mosquitoes, wary of getting Legionnaires disease from poorly maintained air conditioners and amazed that nothing is being done about electricity outages and Bali’s looming water shortage. They are worried about increasing crime and a police force that does nothing without money up-front.
And what does the Tourism Board do to make Bali a more attractive destination for visitors? Nothing. It blames the “stingy tourists.” Wow. What diplomacy; what amazing sensitivity. What a truly stupid, irresponsible thing to say.
Ida Bagus Ngurah Wijaya, I have news for you. Tourists have been coming to Bali for decades because it has a special sort of magic. The magic is still there, but it is now being countered by a not-so-special sort of opportunism and greed, over-development, collapsing infrastructure and an arrogant belief that tourists will keep coming, no matter what.
They won’t. They have already stopped coming; and those who do still come are spending less. Tourists are changing the Bali paradigm, not because they are “stingy,” but because they are driven by the concept of value for money. And frankly, Bali simply does not provide value for money any more.
The question for you, sir, is what will you and your cohorts in government do to change this?
Filed under: Vyt's Line